In the early 1990s, Bhanwari Devi, a Base-level activist in rural Rajasthan,
faced brutal retaliation for her efforts to raise voice against social
injustices like child marriage. After attempting to stop the illegal marriage of
a one-year-old girl in a dominant caste family, Bhanwari was gang-raped by five
men. Her pursuit of justice was met with systemic failures, including mishandled
evidence and biased court proceedings, resulting in the acquittal of the accused
in 1995.
Her ordeal spurred women's rights groups across India, highlighting the
pervasive issue of workplace harassment and the absence of a legal framework to
address it. These efforts led to the filing of a Public Interest Litigation (PIL)
in the Supreme Court under the banner of "Vishakha."
The Supreme Court,in1997 issued the landmark Vishakha Guidelines, which defined
sexual harassment as a violation of constitutional rights and highlighted
measures to ensure workplace safety. These guidelines were a huge and
transformative step towards gender equality and institutional accountability,
inspired by Bhanwari Devi's courage and the collective advocacy it sparked.
This Significant case reshaped India's legal landscape, turning a personal
tragedy into a movement that empowered women nationwide to fight for workplace
safety and justice.
Bhanwari Devi Courage in the In the face of hardships
Bhanwari Devi was a saathin, or village-level social worker, under the Rajasthan
government's Women's Development Program. Her activities involved highlighting
awareness against dowry, child marriage, and other things inappropriate to the
concept of gender equality, which were firmly rooted in the patriarchal way of
thinking of the society. In 1992, she reported an illegal child marriage in a
dominant caste family. That resistant gesture, seen as an attempt to dishonor to
their power, brought on a horrific act of retaliation: she was gang-raped by
five men from the village.
The ordeal that occurred to Bhanwari Devi was not just a crime of physical
violence but a manifestation of systemic oppression that combined gender,caste,
and power.Later, a series of institutional failures were unfolded: the lethargy
in law enforcement, poor handling of evidence, and the alarming acquittal of the
accused in the trial court in 1995. This acquittal highlighted the existing
apathy toward crimes against women, especially those from the marginalized
communities.
The Turning Point: A Catalyst for Legal Reform
The failure of the judiciary in Bhanwari Devi's case sparked widespread outrage and mobilized women's rights groups across the country. Recognizing the gravity of the situation, a group of women's organizations filed a public interest litigation (PIL) in the Supreme Court of India under the collective name Vishakha, seeking protection against sexual harassment in workplaces.
The petition highlighted the absence of a comprehensive legal framework addressing workplace harassment and urged the judiciary to establish guidelines to prevent such atrocities. The Supreme Court took
suo motu cognizance of the matter, acknowledging the systemic nature of gender-based violence and the urgent need for legal safeguards.
The Vishakha Guidelines: A Landmark Judgment
The Supreme Court passed this landmark judgment in
Vishakha v. State of Rajasthan on August 13, 1997, and this case became a landmark in Indian legal history.
It held that sexual harassment is a violation of the basic rights of:
- Equality before the law under Article 14
- Prohibition of discrimination under Article 15
- Right to practice any profession under Article 19(1)(g)
- Right to life and personal dignity under Article 21
The Vishakha Guidelines laid down comprehensive measures to prevent and address sexual harassment in the workplace. The guiding instructions were on:
- Definition of Sexual Harassment: The policy defined sexual harassment in an all-encompassing manner to include physical conduct, verbal conduct, and non-verbal conduct of a sexual nature.
- Employer Responsibility: Employers were mandated to take proactive steps to ensure a safe working environment. This included formulating policies against harassment and instituting grievance mechanisms.
- Internal Complaints Committees (ICC): Workplaces were required to establish ICCs to handle complaints confidentially and impartially.
- Awareness and Training: It was directed that organizations should conduct periodic training and awareness programs to sensitize employees about sexual harassment.
- Accountability: Employers were held liable for negligence in implementing these guidelines, ensuring that institutions could no longer overlook workplace harassment.
These were binding guidelines and remained the most crucial framework for
addressing workplace harassment until legislation was formally introduced in
2013.
From Guidelines to Law: The Sexual Harassment Act of 2013
The Vishakha Guidelines were a monumental step forward but were not without
limitations. Their implementation was often inconsistent, particularly in
informal and unregulated sectors. Recognizing the need for a more robust legal
framework, Parliament passed the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace
(Prevention, Prohibition, and Redressal) Act, 2013.
This Act codified the principles of the Vishakha Guidelines and addressed
their shortcomings by:
- Expanding the scope of protection to include all workplaces, formal and
informal, and safeguarding women from third-party harassment.
- Establishing penalties for non-compliance, ensuring accountability for
employers.
- Providing a statutory backing to the ICC mechanism, making its formation
mandatory in organizations with ten or more employees.
- This law remains a cornerstone of workplace safety in India, yet its
implementation continues to face challenges, particularly in rural areas and
informal sectors.
The Broader Impact: A Cultural and Legal Awakening
The Vishakha Guidelines changed not only the policies at workplaces but also the
cultural discussion on sexual harassment. For the first time, the issue came
into the open and was seen as a systemic problem that needed institutional
intervention.
The guidelines further influenced other legislative changes, like the Criminal
Law Amendment Act, 2013, that expanded the definition of sexual offenses and
provided more stringent punishments for offenders. The talk about harassment at
the workplace has slowly turned from silence to action, though there is still a
lot of stigma associated with it in society.
Bhanwari Devi's Legacy: A Continuing Fight for Justice
Bhanwari Devi's case remains a potent reminder of how inter-sectionality works
to silence people at all levels in India: gender, caste, and class intermingle
to conceal already silenced voices. This is despite the personal cost of
becoming an activist and in spite of being denied justice in her own case, the
struggle of Bhanwari Devi has empowered many women to seek accountability and
redress.
That the Vishakha Guidelines moved from a judicial decree to a statutory law has
its essential base rooted in the power of individual courage and collective
advocacy. Though much has been achieved, the journey for an equitably oriented
society is yet incomplete. The Bhanwari Devi case is a rallying cry for action
against deep-seated systemic barriers to justice for women and, particularly,
for those from poor, marginalized communities.
Conclusion: The Road Ahead
The Vishakha Guidelines are more than just a legal milestone; they symbolize a
shift in the narrative surrounding workplace safety and women's rights in India.
Born out of tragedy, they serve as a beacon of hope, reminding us that even in
the face of systemic failures, change is possible.
But the battle is far from over. It is only when these laws start getting
effectively implemented and the attitudes of society get reshaped that
workplaces will truly emerge as spaces for dignity and equality. The case of
Bhanwari Devi and the legal changes she forced serve to remind us that justice
is not solely a legal but a social enterprise.
Her legacy, enshrined in the Vishakha Guidelines and the laws they inspired,
continues to resonate as a call to action—a demand for accountability, equality,
and the unwavering belief that every woman has the right to live and work
without fear.
Please Drop Your Comments