Legal Protection For Healthcare Whistleblowers In India
Healthcare sector plays a pivotal role in overall development and well being
of a society. It is indeed an important segment for determining a country's
overall human development index and standard of life. It encompasses a wide
network of individuals and organisation involved in providing various services
and aid to ensure a healthy and fit society.
Despite of providing such lucrative contributions to humanity and generating
employment to millions, this sector is facing problems malpractices like
corruption, adulteration, unethical pharmaceutical promotions, and not adhering
to medical standards. In this context, whistleblowers play an important role in
combating these practices by alerting authorities and the public to negligence
or misconduct.
They ensure transparency, checks meeting of ethical standards, and drives needed
reforms in health care system. Despite of facing risks such as firing from jobs,
and legal battles, they contribute significantly to create a valiant system.
Their efforts not only protect the patients but in addition to that give
confidence to other health works and inspire them to work with honesty and
ethics. This article talks about the Legal protection for healthcare
whistleblowers in India.
Historic Background
Historically, there were not much recognition about any law addressing this
issue. In fact, its arised from various social, ethical and professional demands
of various individuals working in the industry. The Indian government approved
the Public Interest Disclosures Bill, 2010, which was later renamed the Whistle
Blower's Protection Bill, 2011. The Lok Sabha passed this bill on December 27,
2011, followed by Rajya Sabha approval on February 21, 2014. The Act received
presidential assent on May 9, 2014, officially becoming the Whistle Blowers
Protection Act, 2014.
Legal Framework Protecting Whistleblowers
The legislation protecting whistleblowers in India is the Whistle Blowers
Protection Act, 2014. It safeguards whistleblowers from retaliation, such as
dismissal, demotion, or harassment. It encompasses with brief knowledge of
whistleblowers, their legal protection and laying down key definitions. For
instance, Section 2 of the Act, defines whistleblower as any individual,
including public servants or members of non-governmental organizations, who
makes a public interest disclosure. Section 4 outlines how disclosures should be
made, Section 5 talks about investigation process and Section 7 of the act
provides crucial protections for whistleblowers like Prohibition of
Victimization, Confidentiality Assurance and Penalties for Retaliation.
Why Whistleblowers Must Be Protected: Story of India's first Whistleblower
One notable case that significantly influenced the discourse on whistleblower
protection in India is that of Satyendra Dubey, an engineer who was murdered in
2003 after exposing corruption in highway construction projects. His tragic
death prompted widespread public outrage and calls for stronger legal
protections for whistleblowers. The Supreme Court of India, recognizing the need
for a robust framework to protect individuals who report misconduct, directed
the government to establish mechanisms for safeguarding whistleblowers.
The Need For Whistleblower Protection in Healthcare
The Companies Act, 2013, as well as SEBI (through revisions of Clause 49 of the
Listing Agreement) have made it mandatory for certain classes of companies to
establish mechanisms to receive complaints related to such grievances or
concerns raised by Directors or employees of a company.
The question arises what is the need for Whistleblower protection in healthcare?
Its essential for maintaining ethical standards, ensuring patient safety, and
fostering transparency within the healthcare system. In addition to that, it
helps to combat Medical Scams, Expose Hospital Mismanagement, Build Public
Trust, Fight Fraudulent Practices, and foster accountability.
Challenges Faced by Healthcare Whistleblowers
Health care whistleblowers are always subject to insecurity and harassment. They
are often threatened of legal actions and face professional repercussions. They
are in fact, targeted by their own colleagues and face social and cultural
stigma. These whistleblowers are also subject to social isolation, lack of
support from peers and even supressed due to lack of awareness of their rights.
They may be labelled as disloyal and troublemaker by the institution and job
insecurity.
Rights of Whistleblowers In Healthcare Sector
Whistleblowers have several the rights like right to confidentiality where their
identities protected during the reporting process so that they can report the
misconduct without any fear. . They have the Right to Protection from
Retaliation and ensures job security. They also have the Right to Submit
Complaints to competent authorities such as the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC)
or other relevant bodies responsible for handling disclosures. In addition to
that, the Right to Provide Supporting Evidence enhances the credibility and
investigability of the allegations made. The 2014 act allows whistleblowers to
apply for protection if they face harassment or threats due to their complaint.
Scope for Improvement in The Whistle Blowers Protection Act, Healthcare
sector Perspective
There a huge scope for improvement in the act in terms of healthcare sector.
First of all, it must be expanded to private sector as well as it's only
regulating public sector in current terms. Also, there must be initiatives to
promote anonymous reporting mechanisms which would encourage more individuals to
come forward with information about misconduct without fear of reprisal. In
addition to that training programmes, incentives for whistleblowers, and
Stronger Anti-Retaliation reforms shall improvise on the act and encourage more
honest workers to step in and work towards forming a transparent and anti
corrupt system in healthcare sector.
Conclusion
To conclude with, the prestigious healthcare sector is always hampered by
corrupted activities. The whistleblowers always combat them and hence they are
essential for fostering an environment where individuals can report misconduct
without fear of retribution. The Whistle Blowers Protection Act 2014, provides a
framework for protect these whistleblowers.
Strengthening these provisions is crucial not only for safeguarding their
individual rights but also for promoting transparency and accountability within
India's healthcare system. With Comprehensive scope of new reforms and scope of
development, this act ensures safeguarding people working towards a vision of a
transparent healthcare sector.
Law Article in India
You May Like
Please Drop Your Comments